Ice Cream Soft In Freezer But Everything Else Frozen? Here’s What To Do

Disclosure: We may get commissions for purchases made through links in this post.

There's nothing quite like the satisfaction of indulging in a bowl of your favorite ice cream. But, if you've ever taken an inventory of your freezer, you may have noticed that your ice cream is one of the only things that's soft. The rest of your food is frozen solid, but why? Luckily, we've researched about this to help you out.

In most cases, ice cream that has softened in the freezer can be salvaged by simply placing it back in the freezer for a few hours. However, there are a few things to keep in mind, especially in checking your freezer and ice cream:

  1. Temperature Setting
  2. Freezer Vent Blockage
  3. Freezer Too Empty
  4. Outside Temperature Too Hot Or Too Cold
  5. Door Seal
  6. Frost Buildup
  7. Dirty Condenser Coils
  8. Evaporator Fan
  9. Refrigerator’s compressor

So what's going on here? Why does ice cream stay soft while the rest of our food freezes? Well, let's take a look at some of the science behind it!

Chocolate Ice Cream, Ice Cream Soft In Freezer But Everything Else Frozen? Here's What To Do

What Could Be The Problem If Your Ice Cream Is Soft But Everything Else Is Frozen Solid In Your Freezer?

Have you ever opened your freezer to find that your ice cream is soft, but everything else is frozen? There are a few possible explanations for this phenomenon.

Full of bucket container ice creams flavors and ice cubes in freezer

Temperature Setting

If you've ever found your ice cream soft in the freezer but everything else frozen, it's likely due to the temperature setting. Most freezers should be set to -15 degrees Fahrenheit (-26 degrees Celsius) in order to maintain optimal freezing conditions.

First, it's important to check the temperature of your freezer. If it's set too low, ice cream can freeze solid, making it difficult to scoop. Conversely, if the temperature is set too high, ice cream can become soft and runny. This can also happen if the door of the freezer is left open for too long, allowing warm air to enter and raise the temperature inside.

With a little trial and error, you'll find the perfect sweet spot for all of your favorite frozen treats.

Freezer Vent Blockage

One possible explanation for why your ice cream is soft but everything else in your freezer is frozen is that the freezer vent might be blocked. The freezer vent helps to regulate the temperature in the freezer by releasing cold air into the compartment. If the vent is blocked, it can cause the air to circulate poorly, causing ice cream to soften and other items to become frozen.

Freezer Too Empty

If you find that your ice cream is soft, but everything else in your freezer is frozen, it's likely because your freezer is too empty. When a freezer is too empty, there's not enough cold air circulating to keep everything frozen.

The solution is simple: add more food to your freezer! By filling up your freezer, you'll create more insulation, and cold air will be better distributed, keeping everything frozen solid.

So next time you find yourself with soft ice cream, just grab some more groceries and restock your freezer.

Outside Temperature Too Hot Or Too Cold

If your ice cream is soft when everything else in the freezer is frozen, it means that the outside temperature is too hot or too cold. The ideal temperature for storing ice cream is -5 degrees Fahrenheit.

But, if it gets warmer than that, the ice cream will start to melt and will become soft. On the other hand, if the temperature gets too cold, the ice cream will become hard and difficult to scoop.

So if you want your ice cream to be perfect, make sure to keep an eye on the outside temperature!

Door Seal

If you find that your ice cream is soft in the freezer, but everything else is frozen, there's a good chance that the door seal is damaged. The seal is what keeps the cold air in and the warm air out, so if it's not functioning properly, the interior of your freezer will warm up and cause the ice cream to soften.

Simply open the freezer door and inspect the seal to see if there are any cracks or gaps. If so, you'll need to replace the seal. Once you've done that, your ice cream should stay frozen solid.

Frost Buildup

If you notice that your ice cream is soft, but everything else in your freezer is frozen solid, it's likely that you have a frost buildup. This can happen for several reasons, but the most common is when warm air enters the freezer and condenses on the cold surfaces.

As this moisture freezes, it can cause frost to build up on the evaporator coils, which can lead to ice cream that's softer than usual. If you suspect that you have a frost buildup, be sure to check your freezer's seals and gaskets to see if they're tight and in good condition. You should also clean any debris from the coils and make sure that the vents are clear.

By taking these simple steps, you can help prevent frost buildup and keep your ice cream at peak deliciousness.

Dirty Condenser Coils

External air-cooled condenser used in water cooler or refrigerator

One plausible reason is dirty condenser coils. When these coils become covered in dust and dirt, they lose their ability to regulate temperature effectively.

As a result, the ice cream can thaw while the rest of the freezer remains cold. If you suspect that your condenser coils are to blame for the softened ice cream, be sure to clean them according to the manufacturer's instructions.

With clean coils, your freezer should be able to keep everything frosty - including your favorite flavor of ice cream.

Evaporator Fan

The evaporator fan circulates cold air throughout the freezer compartment. If the fan isn't working properly, the air can become too warm, causing ice cream to soften while everything else remains frozen. Sometimes, the evaporator fan may also make noise as it struggles to circulate air.

If you notice either of these problems, it's time to call a repairman. A failing evaporator fan is a serious issue that can cause extensive damage to your freezer. Left unchecked, it can lead to a complete loss of power, leaving your food to thaw and spoil.

Don't take chances with your food - if you suspect your evaporator fan is failing, call a repairman right away.

Refrigerator’s Compressor

The compressor is responsible for circulating chilled air throughout the fridge, and it cycles on and off as needed to maintain a consistent temperature. If the compressor isn't working properly, it can cause the air inside the fridge to become too warm, which can, in turn, lead to soft ice cream.

Fortunately, this problem is usually relatively easy to fix. Simply check the coils on the back of your fridge to ensure that they're not covered in dust or debris, and if they are, give them a good cleaning. In most cases, this will be enough to get your compressor up and running again.

By taking these simple steps, you can help ensure that your ice cream stays nice and creamy.

What Should You Do If Your Ice Cream Is Soft But Everything Else Is Frozen Solid In The Freezer?

scooping vanilla ice cream with spoon

Besides checking the freezer's status, you can also check the ice cream itself. If your ice cream is soft, but everything else is frozen solid in the freezer, there are a few things you can do.

Check the Quality of the Ice Cream

First, check to see if the ice cream has expired. If it has, it's best to discard it. If the ice cream is still good, try placing it in the freezer for a few hours to see if it will harden up.

If it doesn't, you can try putting it in an airtight container and putting it in the fridge for a bit. This won't make it as solid as it would be if it was properly frozen, but it will help to make it more scoopable.

Refreeze Your Ice Cream

Remove the ice cream from the freezer. Next, place it in a bowl and put it in the refrigerator for about 15-20 minutes. This will allow the ice cream to soften slightly without melting completely.

Once it has reached your desired consistency, return it to the freezer and enjoy!

Seal Ice Cream Container Properly

Another possibility is that the ice cream was simply not stored properly. If ice cream is not tightly sealed, it can allow air to seep in, which can cause it to become soft.

Be sure to seal it tightly in an airtight container before placing it in the freezer. If those don't solve the problem, you might need to wrap your ice cream more tightly before storing it in the freezer.

How To Prevent This From Happening Again?

DIsh of vanilla soft-serve frozen yogurt surrounded by a variety of fresh fruits

To prevent ice cream from getting too soft, there are a few things you can do.

  1. First, put the ice cream in the coldest part of the freezer.
  2. You can also try placing it on a shelf instead of in the door, where it will be exposed to warmer air every time you open the freezer.
  3. Finally, consider wrapping the container in plastic wrap or aluminum foil. This will help to keep as much cold air in as possible.

By following these tips, you can help to keep your ice cream nice and firm.

Final Thoughts

Chocolate Ice Cream

It's a little confusing when you see ice cream soft in the freezer, but everything else is frozen. So make sure to review the possible reasons listed above to see why some of your food is freezing and why your ice cream is still soft. Also, keep on checking the quality of your freezer and the food you are placing inside.

To get more tips on how to manage your kitchen, see our posts below:

How To Reset A Frigidaire Refrigerator

How Much Space Should You Have Around A Fridge

Fridge Not Cooling But Light Is On – What To Do?

Leave a Reply