11 Best Alternatives For Nutella [Plus 2 Homemade Options!]

Are you a Nutella fan looking for other alternatives to the tasty hazelnut spread? If so, you've come to the right place. We have pulled together almost a dozen different alternatives for the butter-flavored chocolate treat, and in this post, we will go over them with you.

Here are 11 of the best Nutella alternatives to consider:

  1. Justin’s Chocolate Hazelnut and Almond Butter
  2. Hey, Hey Hazelnut!
  3. Artisana Organics Hazelnut Cacao Spread
  4. Natural ChocoDream
  5. Hershey’s Chocolate with Hazelnut Spread
  6. Nocciolata
  7. Rawmio
  8. NutiLight
  9. Meridian Cocoa & Hazelnut Butter
  10. Cadbury’s Smooth Chocolate Spread 
  11. Eliot's Nut Butters Spread, Oregon Hazelnut Chocolate

There are all kinds of reasons why you may want to find a Nutella alternative. Perhaps the spread is too expensive for your liking, or maybe you prefer something a bit healthier. Whatever your reason, there are quite a few options to pick instead. Let's take a look at the most popular ones.

chocolate spread with bread on a white plate. 11 Best Alternatives For Nutella [Plus 2 Homemade Options!]

11 Best Alternatives For Nutella

If you are looking for a healthier alternative for Nutella, be sure to read the label instructions. Because while some alternatives may have a lower sugar count, they may have a higher fat percentage, which is worth noting.

Nougat cream on cookie

1. Justin’s Chocolate Hazelnut and Almond Butter

In the past 15 years, the Justin's brand has effectively marked its place in the nut butter industry. This chocolate, hazelnut, and almond butter mixture has a very nutty flavor and goes perfectly with fruit, bread, or cheese.

It's a less sugary alternative to Nutella, though the texture is thicker. You may find that it's a bit more expensive than Nutella, but definitely worth it if you prefer something with a nuttier flavor profile.

Find it on Amazon.

2. Hey, Hey Hazelnut!

Do you prefer something with dark chocolate instead of milk chocolate? If so, this hazelnut spread is just for you. It has a super-rich cocoa flavor, but it doesn't offer the hazelnut flavor profile as Nutella.

So if you prefer something that isn't as sweet or that doesn't have any nuttiness to it, this may be an option worth considering. It's worth noting that this spread is around the same price as Nutella, starting at about $6 per jar. Buy it online.

3. Artisana Organics Hazelnut Cacao Spread

This popular Nutella alternative is super creamy, and the nutty flavor is consistent with that of Nutella --not to mention that this option has a very chocolatey flavor profile. While it tastes very similar to Nutella, it's made with more natural ingredients.

It has high sugar and fat content, so if you are looking for something a bit healthier, this may not be the best choice. You can purchase this spread in select grocery stores or online.

Learn more on Amazon.

4. Natural ChocoDream

Here is another alternative that can give you a run for your money. It has about the same viscosity as Nutella, though it's a bit creamier. The only downside to this alternative is the potential aftertaste that many consumers have mentioned in its reviews. You can purchase this product online or at most grocery stores.

5. Hershey’s Chocolate with Hazelnut Spread

No brand knows chocolate better than Hershey's. And this hazelnut spread it's just as tasty as it sounds. It has a very heavy chocolate flavor and a slight hint of nuttiness, making it perfect for anyone with a chocolate craving.

Essentially, it tastes like a melted chocolate Hershey's bar with a slight hint of hazelnut. It, however, is a bit cheaper than Nutella, making it noteworthy if you're looking for something similar but with a smaller price tag. Check it out online.

6. Nocciolata

This hazelnut spread is made with organic cocoa and milk. If you are looking for a spread that tastes like Nutella, here is one that comes very close. The consistency is a bit creamier and thinner, but it is just as delicious and about the same price.

Read more on Amazon.

7. Rawmio

Here is an organic and vegan treat that's guaranteed to satisfy your sweet tooth. It's made with only natural ingredients, including raw Peruvian cocoa nibs, hazelnuts, and coconut sugar. It has a creamy texture and is more versatile than other chocolate-hazelnut spreads.

Overall its flavor profile is nutty, and it has a richer taste than many other similar spreads. You also find that this spread is higher and natural minerals as well. On the downside, the spread is one of the most expensive ones on our list, hovering around $20 per jar.

Find out more about it on Amazon.

8. NutiLight

If you suffer from diabetes or are just trying to keep your sugar levels low, here is a sugar-free option to consider. Nutilight is free of gluten, cholesterol, and sugar. It's also free of hydrogenated oils and is a better choice for anyone with celiac disease and other sugar-sensitive ailments.

This dark chocolate and hazelnut spread is just as sweet as Nutella but without the milky taste that the spread offers. If you are a fan of dark chocolate and don't mind paying a few dollars extra for an alternative, here is one to check out.

See it on Amazon here.

9. Meridian Cocoa & Hazelnut Butter

This nutty hazelnut spread goes perfectly with snacks, pastries, or your morning pancakes. Meridian has a brilliantly smooth texture and flavor, which is in no small part due to the simplicity of its ingredients. It's made of honey, coconut, and hazelnuts.

And you'll be happy to know that it contains no refined sugar, salt, or palm oil. If you are a vegetarian or prefer a simple hazelnut spread, take a look at this one.

Find this product on Amazon.

10. Cadbury’s Smooth Chocolate Spread

Cadbury's famous milk chocolate spread goes on smooth and has no weird aftertaste. This easy spread is nut-free and rich in flavor and texture. If you love the rich taste of milk chocolate and don't need the added hazelnut flavor, this spread may be perfect for you.

It's great on ice cream, cakes, toast, and cheese. The biggest downside is that this fancy spread costs about twice with you pay for Nutella.

Check it out on Amazon.

11. Eliot's Nut Butters Spread, Oregon Hazelnut Chocolate

This nut butter by Eliot's is making a name in the nut nutter industry with this tasty Nutella alternative. It is made from local nuts and is perfect for fruit, toast, cheese, and pancakes. It only contains five ingredients and is non-GMO, gluten-free, and preservative-free.

You won't be disappointed in the simplicity of its ingredients, as it offers a very rich and creamy flavor profile. The only downside to this spread is its price, which hovers around $12 per jar. However, the jar is 12 ounces, which is five ounces bigger than the Nutella jar.

Read more about it on Amazon.

Homemade Nutella Alternatives

Let's look at a couple of ways to make your own Nutella-like spread at home.

Toasts with chocolate spread

The Cooking Foodie DIY Nutella

If you don't mind purchasing and cooking roasting your hazelnuts, this recipe may be just for you. In addition to the hazelnuts, you only need a bit of cocoa powder, milk chocolate, sugar, vanilla extract, and you're all set.

After roasting the hazelnuts and combining the ingredients, you can have your Nutella made in about 20 minutes from start to finish. Take a look at the recipe ">here.

Minimalist Baker DIY Vegan Nutella

If you prefer a vegan option for your Nutella recipe, you can make this easy alternative with sea salt, vanilla extract, hazelnuts, and dairy-free dark chocolate. There are also additional options for the chocolate available. Find out how to make it here.

Why is Nutella so expensive?

This is a common question among Nutella fans, and the reason is simple: the ingredients are expensive. Nutella is very simple to make, but the cost of hazelnuts, cacao powder, and palm oil have higher prices than ingredients like sugar. The hazelnuts that Nutella uses are very high quality, as is the cacao powder and vanilla extract used in the spread.

Will Nutella stop using palm oil?

Nutella has not made any public statements stating that it will stop using palm oil. They do, however, carefully treat the palm oil during its manufacturing process to ensure that it is sustainable and free of harmful contaminants.

Is there a vegan version of Nutella?

At the moment, there is not a vegan version of Nutella. However, there are vegan alternatives that you can consider.

Which chocolate spread is the healthiest?

Two chocolate spreads that are known for being similar to Nutella but healthier include Justin's Chocolate Hazelnut Butter and Barefoot & Chocolate spread. Both spreads have lower sugar than Nutella, which is typically the main health concern for these types of spreads.

What is a hazelnut spread good for?

Hazelnut spread is the perfect addition to breakfast pastries, snacks, or sweets. It goes wonderfully with cheese spreads, waffles, toasted bread, and other baked snacks.

Is Hershey's spread better than Nutella?

It depends on who you ask. The Hershey spread is a bit cheaper than Nutella, and the flavor profile is notable. Many consumers, however, have mentioned that it doesn't have the same nutty taste as Nutella and that its aftertaste is more chocolatey.

Is Nutella healthier than peanut butter?

No. Peanut butter is generally referred to as the healthier option when compared to Nutella. It typically contains less sugar and fewer added ingredients. It also contains more minerals and nutrients due to the peanuts.

Slice of Toasted brioche with Chocolate Spread. 11 Best Alternatives For Nutella [Plus 2 Homemade Options!]

Wrapping Things Up

We hope this post has helped you discover a few Nutella alternatives. Remember to always look at the sugar and fat content on the label if you're looking to compare nutrient information to the other options.

Leave a Reply