What To Do If You Don’t Have A Cookie Sheet

Disclosure: We may get commissions for purchases made through links in this post.

You are probably wondering what to do if you want to bake cookies and do not have a cookie sheet. We have researched all about this and have found the best answers for you. Here we will discuss what the best methods are for baking without a cookie sheet.

If you do not have a cookie sheet, you can use a variety of alternatives. Some alternatives to a cookie sheet include a silicone pan, an aluminum baking pan, a muffin tin, a cast-iron skillet, a glass pan, porcelain bakeware, or a pizza stone.

Keep reading to learn more about baking without a cookie sheet. You will learn whether or not you can use aluminum foil as a substitute, whether or not cookies can be baked without parchment paper, whether or not stoneware is good for baking cookies, if it takes longer to bake cookies when using stoneware, and whether or not you can bake cookies in a glass dish.

A cookie sheet with freshly baked chocolate cookies, What To Do If You Don't Have A Cookie Sheet

How to Make Cookies Without A Cookie Sheet

When baking cookies without a cookie sheet, you will want to be sure to line your alternative with parchment paper or a non-stick cooking spray. This is the best way to ensure your cookies do not stick to the surface that they are being baked on.

Baking Cookies Using a Silicone Pan

Silicone pans are a good alternative to a cookie sheet because silicone will not melt in the oven. There are several options available when choosing the right silicone baking pan for you. Some silicone pans are made specifically for cake while others are made to be more like a cookie sheet.

Click here to see these silicone baking pans on Amazon.

Aluminum Baking pan

Aluminum baking pans are an option for baking cookies when you do not have a cookie sheet. You can buy the more flimsy kind that will require more care when removing them from the oven, but there are also more sturdy options available.

Click here to see this set of 3 aluminum baking pans on Amazon.

Baking Cookies with a Muffin Tin

Another option for baking cookies without a cookie sheet is to use a muffin tin. If you decide to use a muffin tin, there are a couple of options for how to go about it. You can either use wax-lined muffin liners, spray non-stick cooking spray on muffin liners that are not wax-lined, or spray non-stick cooking spray on the muffin tin directly.

Some muffin tins are made to be non-stick, but adding a second layer of protection will not hurt. If you do not have non-stick cooking spray or muffin liners, you can coat your muffin tin with butter and lightly sprinkle flour over the butter to help prevent your cookies from sticking.

Click here to see this USA Pan Bakeware on Amazon.

How to Bake Using a Cast-iron Skillet

If you would like to bake in a cast-iron skillet or even a stainless steel skillet, you can do so. Be sure the handle is also metal and that it is deemed oven-safe if you choose to use a stainless steel skillet. With both of these alternatives, you can either use parchment paper or a non-stick cooking spray to coat them prior to adding your cookie dough. As with everything you take out of the oven, use an oven mitt or layer of protection when removing the pan.

Click here to see this Cuisinel Cast Iron Skillet on Amazon.

Click here to see this non-stick stainless steel skillet on Amazon.

Baking Cookies in a Glass Pan

Baking in glass pans can be tricky. Some glass pans will shatter if they are exposed to high temperatures especially when set onto a cold surface while still extremely hot. One way to avoid this is to leave the pan in your oven until it cools completely. Another way to combat this is to set your oven temperature to 25°F lower than what your recipe calls for and bake for an additional ten minutes longer than the suggested time.

Something you should know about baking with glassware is that glass works as an insulator rather than a conductor. This results in glass heating more slowly yet retains heat for a longer period of time. Because food does not bake as evenly when using a glass pan, only use this alternative if you do not have one of the others available to you.

Click here to see this oven-safe glass baking dish on Amazon.

Porcelain Bakeware

Food bakes evenly in porcelain dishes. Porcelain can withstand high temperatures. It is still an important rule of thumb to always check for an "oven-safe" marking on the bottom of whatever dish you are baking with.

Click here to see this oven-safe set of porcelain bakeware on Amazon.

Baking on a Pizza Stone

A pizza stone is one more alternative for baking if you do not have a cookie sheet. Pizza stones are made to withstand high temperatures. These can be made from stainless steel, wood, ceramic, or cast iron.

Click here to see this Heritage Pizza Stone on Amazon.

Click here to see this Augosta wooden pizza stone on Amazon.

Can you use aluminum foil if you don't have a baking sheet?

In theory, you can use heavy-duty aluminum foil to bake if you do not have a baking sheet. You do not ever want to bake on aluminum foil alone. This is best when combined with an alternative baking dish if you do not have a baking sheet. Aluminum foil disrupts the distribution of heat and it is flimsy which makes it dangerous to remove standing alone. This is different than using an aluminum baking dish because they are thicker and made to be used inside the oven by itself.

Can cookies be baked without parchment paper?

You can bake cookies without parchment paper. The purpose of using parchment paper is to help the cookies not stick to your baking dish. A non-stick cooking spray, butter, or oil are great alternatives to using parchment paper. Some more alternatives to parchment paper include aluminum foil, wax paper, and a silicone baking mat.

Is stoneware good for baking cookies?

Stoneware is a fantastic choice for baking cookies. Stoneware is durable and can withstand extremely high temperatures. It is also chip-resistant and can be used over and over again. One piece of advice when using stoneware is to not use the same stoneware for pizza and cookies. Keep two stoneware dishes on hand so that you can alternate them which will help you to avoid making your cookies taste like pizza.

Do cookies take longer on stoneware?

Stoneware is heavy-duty therefore it does take longer to heat up and cool down. You will have to adjust your cooking time because of this. It only takes a couple more minutes to bake with stoneware so keep a close eye on your food until you get used to baking with it.

In closing

There are many alternatives to baking when you do not have a cookie sheet or baking sheet. These alternatives vary between a plethora of oven-safe materials. Silicone, stainless steel, cast-iron, porcelain, and glass are some examples of materials that can be used for baking when you do not have a cookie sheet.

Before you go, check out the following links to learn more about your options of baking dishes:

10 Best Baking Dishes For Convection Ovens

25 Types Of Baking Dishes You Need In Your Kitchen

Leave a Reply