Should You Rinse Pasta For Mac And Cheese?

We may get commissions for purchases made through links in this post.

Is your pot of mac and cheese pasta boiling? At this point, you may be wondering if you should rinse your pasta when it’s done cooking. Look no further. We have done the work to bring you the answer.

No, you should not rinse pasta for this dish. As the water boils and the pasta cooks, starch forms in the water. Without the presence of this starch, the sauce will not stick to your pasta!

Continue reading to learn more about whether or not you are supposed to wash pasta before cooking, if it is healthier to rinse pasta, and whether or not you should add pasta water to macaroni and cheese. We’ve also answered if you salt the water for macaroni and cheese, and how to keep macaroni and cheese creamy, so you’ll be guaranteed a tasty result for your dish!

A man preparing and rinsing his pasta on a stainless strainer, Should You Rinse Pasta For Mac And Cheese?

To Rinse or Not to Rinse Pasta

A casserole of mac and cheese on a serving board

You should not rinse pasta. This is mainly because when pasta boils, it creates starch in the water. The starch that remains present makes it so the sauce of your choice can adhere to the pasta.

If you rinse your pasta in cold water, it will cool the pasta quickly. You do not want that when you intend to eat or serve it immediately.

Are you supposed to wash pasta before cooking?

No, it is not necessary to wash raw pasta. Even rinsing cooked pasta is its own debate. The main concern is that when you rinse pasta, it cools it down quickly and causes the chosen sauce to not stick to the noodles.

It is not a good idea to eat raw pasta. This is because it is more difficult to digest. In addition, your body does not absorb the nutrients in the same way it does after eating pasta that has been cooked.

Is it healthier to rinse pasta?

It is not particularly healthier to rinse pasta. Rinsing pasta removes starch from the surface of the noodles, though. If you prefer to have as little starch as possible in your diet, but still enjoy pasta, then rinsing it for that reason could be considered healthier.

Note that when you rinse pasta, it will be cooled, preventing your sauce from absorbing. This is one of the main reasons why you should not rinse your pasta.

It is recommended to rinse your pasta only when making cold pasta dishes such as pasta salad. Rinsing not only cools the pasta, as we’ve discussed, but for cold salads, rinsing makes the noodles loose rather than clumped together. Try rinsing when you make the following:

  • Italian pasta salad
  • Strawberry pasta salad
  • Avocado pasta salad
  • Lemon pepper shrimp pasta salad

Another helpful tip to know about rinsing pasta is that it halts the cooking process. This keeps the noodles the desired firmness. Always remember to drain your pasta well after rinsing it.

Should you add pasta water to mac and cheese?

No, you should not add pasta water to macaroni and cheese. You should not put in any additional water when making the dish. In fact, for boxed macaroni and cheese, you drain the water after the macaroni noodles are finished cooking.

On the other hand, if you make macaroni and cheese from scratch, you can save your pasta water. You should still drain the macaroni noodles when they are done cooking. In this case, save two cups of pasta water and just keep it aside until you are ready to use it in the cheese sauce –you’ll see!

While your macaroni noodles are boiling, you can start your cheese sauce. When making your sauce, you should melt two tablespoons of butter in a large pot or dutch oven. Add one cup of milk to the melted butter, bring to a simmer, and whisk six more tablespoons of butter into your milk and butter mixture.

This is where the pasta water comes in handy. Add one-half of a cup of pasta water at a time while adding in your grated Parmesan one third at a time. Only add the amount of pasta water necessary to result in the desired amount of sauce.

Do you salt the water for macaroni and cheese?

Yes, you should salt the water for macaroni and cheese, just like any other pasta dish. The reason for salting pasta water is so that the pasta can absorb the salt while it cooks. This enhances the flavor of your dish.

If you salt your pasta after it is finished cooking, the flavors will not have had a chance to meld. Salting your pasta water before or while the pasta is cooking gives the pasta the chance to absorb the salt.

When you add salt to the water, it increases the boiling point. If you end up with too salty pasta, you can add half of an uncooked potato to your sauce. This adds some extra starch to the dish, which will, in turn, make your pasta less salty.

How do you keep mac and cheese creamy?

Scooping a spoonful of mac and cheese in a skillet

One way to make macaroni and cheese creamy is to substitute half-and-half or heavy cream for milk. You can also substitute yogurt or mascarpone.

Another option for a creamy macaroni and cheese dish is using evaporated milk and American cheese. Both are processed and stay creamy even at room temperature.

In order to make your cheese sauce thicker, you can add cornstarch or flour. Whenever you do this, you need to use a whisk and allow it to simmer.

Parmesan cheese will cause the sauce to thicken as it cools as long as you do not add too much water. Always drain your macaroni noodles when they are finished cooking, and do not add water until the right time while whisking up a cheese sauce.

Whenever you use flour to thicken sauce, remember to let it simmer long enough to cook out the floury flavor. If you choose to use cornstarch instead, make sure you use the right amount.

Be thoughtful when choosing the cheese or cheeses for your macaroni and cheese dish. Sharp cheddar is the most commonly used cheese for macaroni and cheese.

You can also use parmesan cheese, gruyere (which melts similarly to cheddar), or gouda as alternatives to cheddar cheese. Using a slow cooker is another way to make a creamy mac and cheese dish.

Tips and Tricks When Boiling Pasta

Do not add oil to your boiling water. Doing so makes your pasta slippery, and your sauce won’t stick as well. If you prefer, you can smother your pasta with oil after it is cooked and drained instead.

Something helpful to know when cooking pasta is that you can cook pasta in a sauce. Whether it is spaghetti sauce, pesto, or another delicious variety –just keep in mind how pasta works while it is boiling. You should remember to add extra liquid to cook in the sauce because pasta is absorbent. It takes longer to cook pasta in a sauce than it does in boiling water.

Up close photo of mac and cheese

Pasta will become overcooked if you leave it in the boiling water for more than about one or two additional minutes. Stir your pasta often to help prevent it from sticking and clumping up.

When you reheat sauced pasta, you should do so on the stovetop rather than in the microwave. When you warm pasta up in the microwave, it can easily become dried out or lose flavor.

In Closing

Overall, you should not rinse your pasta for macaroni and cheese. Instead, it is recommended to leave the starches on the noodles made when boiling your pasta. This helps ensure that your sauce will adhere to your pasta.

The only time you should really rinse your pasta is for cold pasta dishes such as pasta salad. Doing so stops the cooking process, cools off your pasta, and helps it not clump together.

For creamy macaroni and cheese, you can substitute half-and-half or heavy cream for milk. Include a roux, cornstarch, or Parmesan cheese to thicken your sauce. Allow your sauce to simmer for an appropriate length of time, and remember it will thicken as it cools.

Before you go, check out the following links for all pasta lovers:

Do Pasta And Noodles Absorb Water When Cooked?

How Long Should You Cook Lasagna? [Including The Pasta Noodles & Time In Oven]

Can You Eat Raw Pasta And Noodles?

Leave a Reply