Keurig Tastes Watered Down – What To Do?

Disclosure: We may get commissions for purchases made through links in this post.

Keurig coffee machines are some of the most convenient as they come. A Keurig covers all the prep work for coffee. However, after prolonged use, you may have noticed that your Keurig tastes watered down. Are you curious as to why that is? If you would like to know what could have caused it, we have researched the issue and found some answers!

There are many reasons why your coffee might taste watered down. One cause could be that you are using too much water. Another might be that you might need to double up on the K-cups. Since some coffee drinkers may need a more potent dose of caffeine, one cup is not enough. Lastly, the needle on the machine might not be penetrating the cup you put in.

We have gone over several reasons why your Keurig might be giving you weak coffee. Of course, the causes are not black and white. You would need to get a better understanding of how a Keurig works. Additionally, it is essential to know how potent standard Keurig cups are. If you would like to know this and more, keep reading ahead.

Keurig k-cup coffee maker with three k-cup pods, Keurig Tastes Watered Down - What To Do?

What Are The Causes Of A Watered Down Keurig Brew?

We will have to knock this problem step by step. The first step is to check if your Keurig is clean. If you have used a Keurig for a long time, there might be some dirt build-up in the machine. Dirt build-up will cause blockages which leads to a weaker cup of coffee.

One component we mentioned earlier is the needle. Two needles make a Keurig work. One penetrates the top while the other penetrates the bottom. The top one comes in constant contact with k-cups.

As you might already know, that means bits of residue stick around every time. So, it is essential to keep up with maintenance. However, that is only the needle we are pointing out.

You also have to maintain the water reservoir. The other coffee flow pieces need frequent and thorough cleaning too!

You Might Need A Stronger Flavor

Single serving coffee k-cups

If you favor a less bitter and acidic taste, getting a darker roast might interest you. Of course, this may not apply to all Keurig users. However, some do not know that they are using a lighter roast that does not give off a strong of a taste as they would like. So, what is the difference between a light roast and a dark roast?

Like any cooking process, the longer you leave it under heat, the less water and moisture it will retain. For light roasts, this means they are packing more moisture. A coffee bean with more moisture will give you a herbal flavor and more caffeine. For an energy boost, a light roast will offer that at the sacrifice of a strong-flavored taste. Some describe light roasts as akin to drinking a strong black tea.

In comparison, dark roast coffee stays under the heat longer or at a higher temperature. However, the trade-off here is that it will not contain as much caffeine. But, if you like coffee that resembles caramel, graham crackers, or roasted nuts, darker roasts should be your target!

Double Up On The Cups

Various brands of coffee pods for Keurig single cup coffee makers

What about the people who do not want to switch it up? We all have our preferences. Some consumers like lighter roasts as opposed to darker ones. So, what can you do? The answer is simple.

You double up on your k-cups! However, you need to be cautious as you need to know your caffeine tolerance. While you may be strengthening the taste by doubling up, you are also increasing the amount of caffeine you consume. 

In general, each K-cup contains around 75-150mg of caffeine. That range depends on how you roast the coffee. Even decaffeinated coffee holds a bit of caffeine. So, if you are doubling up, be careful not to give yourself the jitters! 

Take Your Mug Out At The Right Time

Woman having a fresh coffee with a coffee maker machine

Another tip to help you achieve a distinct flavor is to remove your mug on time. What we mean is you should not leave your cup on the Keurig for too long. If you do, there will be an excessive amount of water mixed with your coffee. The excess water will dilute the coffee and will make it taste watery. 

In a nutshell, pull your mug or cup out once it finishes brewing. Do not wait for that extra bit! Otherwise, you will be left wanting more than you got.

How Do You Make Keurig Coffee Stronger?

As mentioned above, you have two options to choose on how to make your coffee stronger. The first one is to switch to a dark roast because it offers an impactful flavor compared to light roasts. Of course, some are not willing to do that because they enjoy the flavor light roasts give. So, for those people, you can choose to double up on your k-cups. 

As a warning, doubling on light roast k-cups also means increasing your caffeine consumption. Be careful and know how much you can tolerate. You might end up taking a trip to the doctor. 

For healthy adults, many recommend consuming less than 400mgs a day. That limit falls lower for people who can tolerate less. As always, be careful.

What Is The Strongest K Cup Coffee?

The meaning of a strong coffee is up to the consumer's interpretation. It could range from a flavorful coffee to a coffee that can give you a boost in energy. Since we can not read your mind, we got a list of both. Some pack a punch while others bring a taste you will not regret. See these coffees on Amazon:

Wake the H*ll Up! Coffee

Click here to see this on Amazon.

Green Mountain Dark Magic

Click here to see this on Amazon.

Gevalia Signature Blend

Click here to see this on Amazon.

Valhalla Java

Click here to see this on Amazon.

Timothy's Rainforest Espresso

Click here to see this on Amazon.

Can You Use K-Cups Twice?

Most Keurig cups only have enough for one serving. If you want to use it again, at best, it will give you a weak flavor. To paint a better picture, think about coffee grounds. After one use, would you reuse them again, expecting the same results? Most likely not. 

The same goes for k-cups. If you want to reuse the same one, there are reusable k-cups available for purchase. However, you will have to fill it with your coffee grounds. 

How Often Should You Clean A Keurig?

How often you clean your Keurig machine depends on where you live. If you do not know, mineral content in water differs from place to place. Some areas have a high mineral content while others have lower. If you use tap water to fill your Keurig machine, the minerals present in the water will build up over time. 

In general, Keurig recommends you descale your machine every 3-6 months. Additionally, your Keurig should remind you to descale once enough water has passed in it. To prevent a lot of mineral build-up, you can opt to use bottled water or filtered water. 

How Do You Clean The Keurig Needle?

Cleaning a Keurig machine is simple. However, you need to proceed with caution. This way, you do not mess up your Keurig. Let us start cleaning!

  • Turn off the machine and unplug. 
  • Take the pod holder out by lifting the handle and pull the pod holder out from the top. 
  • There should be two components in your hand now. The pod holder and the funnel should be distinguishable. Pull them apart with a twist. 
  • Now the bottom of the pod holder should be exposed. Clean the exit needle by inserting a paperclip into the tube present. Move the paper clip inside the tube for 10-30 seconds carefully. 
  • Rinse both the pod holder and the funnel under tap water. Once you finish, dry it with a paper towel.
  • Lift the handle once again to locate the entrance needle. It should be present on the bottom of the top half. 
  • Take your paper clip (or tool if your Keurig came with one) and clean both sides near the entrance needle. 
  • Once the funnel and pod holder are dry, put them back together and place them into the Keurig. 
  • Finally, do a test run with water only by running two cycles at the largest cup size. This process will flush out the leftover grime.

Why Does My Reusable K Cup Not Work?

There are several reasons why your reusable k-cup may not be working. The solution to the problem depends on your situation. We will go over a quick rundown of the troubles you may encounter. 

Machine Won't Recognize The K-Cup

Sometimes machines can be frustrating. In a Keurig's case, it might not recognize a reusable k-cup that you made sure was compatible with it. If this is the case, try repositioning the cup until it is in the middle. Another solution is to clean the laser lens with a q-tip. If these solutions do not work, you will need to purchase a new reusable cup.

Final Takeaway

Machines are the ultimate tool for convenience. But, if we do not know how they work, we will never know how efficiently they are supposed to run. This rule applies to many machines such as Keurigs! Now that we know the potential causes, we can move ahead and enjoy a better coffee experience. We hope you found the article informative and insightful. 

Before you go, do you have other questions about Keurigs? Want to know the difference between a Keurig and drip coffee? Check out our post here.

Do you need some help pairing cinnamon rolls with something for breakfast? We can offer some advice. Check out our post here. Until next time!

Leave a Reply