Can You Rebake Undercooked Quiche?

Disclosure: We may get commissions for purchases made through links in this post.

If you are new to cooking quiche, it's almost expected that you may run into an error the first time or two that you prepare the dish. This is typically due to the preparation and cooking methods used for quiche, which can sometimes take a few tries to perfect due to the egg content of the dish. We've researched the best way to re-bake undercooked quiche. And in this post, we will go over it.

The best way to rebake undercooked quiche is to place it back in the oven for about 10 minutes. Depending on how underbaked the quiche is, you may want to place the oven anywhere from 165 to 250 degrees Fahrenheit. It's best not to go over this temperature range, as you don't want to brown the quiche but cook the runny interior while preventing the exterior from burning.

If your quiche is runny in the middle or soggy, the chances are that you are missing a step in the baking or preparation process. It can also be due to the ingredients that you're adding to your quiche. Continue reading to learn about the most common reasons why a quiche may be undercooked and how to prevent it.

An up close photo of a perfectly cooked French quiche using vegetables and spinach with garlic and tomatoes on the side, Can You Rebake Undercooked Quiche?

Why is my quiche runny in the middle?

Runny quiche is a common scenario in the baking world, particularly with novice bakers. There are a few common reasons why quiche may be runny in the middle after being baked. Let's take a look at the most common ones.

Making the crust incorrectly

A common reason why bakers find that the crust is soggy in the middle of the quiche is liquid is that the egg is poured into the crust while it is still unbaked, causing it to become soggy and preventing it from becoming crisp. The best solution is to do what is known as a "blind bake" above the crust before adding the egg custard.

Perfectly cooked French quiche cooked on a small cooking plate with tomatoes on the side

To do this, put the crust into the pie pan and be sure to line it with quality parchment paper. Next, fill the pan with beans is pie weights. Then set the pan in the oven and bake it for 20 minutes at 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Afterward, remove the beans or pie weights and parchment paper, and then bake the crust for an additional 10 to 15 minutes until it becomes brown. Next, let the crust cool for a few minutes before adding the custard and re-baking it.

Check out these pie weights on Amazon.

Using too many eggs

Using too many eggs can also cause the keys to becoming too runny in the middle--even after it is baked for the recommended time. This can also result in the quiche filling being rubbery or too firm when you attempt to re-bake it to eliminate the runny consistency.

You can prevent this by simply changing up your egg to milk ratio. Start by adding a half cup of milk for every large egg that you use. So, for example, if you use three large eggs, you should add 1 and 1/2 cups of milk to the pie crust. Be sure to blend the eggs and milk thoroughly before pouring them into the ramekin dish.

Check out this blender on Amazon.

Watery vegetables

The previously mentioned tip refers to getting the right consistency using the eggs and milk, but what about adding additional liquids? This usually comes in the form of vegetables, which, if frozen, will contain water that will drip into the crust, making the custard runnier. You want any vegetables or other ingredients that you add to the pie crust to be as dry as possible, or they can cause it to become runny once it's baked.

So to say, it's best first to unthaw any frozen vegetables and then place them on top of a paper towel or clean, dry cloth to the press as much of the water out of them responsible. You can also quickly sautee the veggies to remove all of the moisture. To do this, place the vegetables in a small frying pan and set them on medium heat, and then let them cook for about 5 minutes.

Baking the quiche on the top oven rack

The closer your pie crust is to the oven's heat source, the browner it will be. This can't happen if the pie crust is placed on the top rack, at least not without sacrificing extra time. And this, in turn, can cause the quiche to become overcooked and dry.

To prevent this, be sure to place the quiche on the bottom rack to ensure that each inch of the trust will get golden brown and super crispy. If your quiche is soggy, re-bake it on the bottom shelf for about 10 minutes.

Using the wrong baking dish

High quality ceramic or heavy glass pan is the best material to use when baking crustless quiche. If you use an aluminum pan, you may find that your quiche can be a bit running in the middle, though the exterior may appear well-cooked or even overcooked.

The latter pan type cannot distribute heat and ceramic and glass, and it doesn't have the barrier of the crust to help make this possible. If you run into this problem with your crustless quiche, consider changing the type of man you use.

Learn more about this ramekin set on Amazon

Can you leave an undercooked quiche in the fridge?

While it's generally not recommended to keep undercooked quiche in the refrigerator, you can do so for a brief period of time. For example, if you leave the uncooked dish for up to 24 hours, it should be fine. But any longer than that, and you'll risk ruining the texture of the quiche.

Generally, it's best to cook quiche completely through and then freeze it if you don't want to consume the whole pie at once. You'll be surprised to know that frozen quiche reheats reasonably well.

Can you microwave uncooked quiche?

Yes. You can microwave uncooked quiche. When doing so, you will need to place the uncooked custard in a ramekin bowl to ensure that it molds correctly and does not run all over the place. It's best to blend the custard thoroughly and then pour it into one ramekin bowl, making sure not to fill the bowl more than half an inch away from the top.

Next, set the microwave for 2 and 1/2 minutes and be sure to monitor. To prevent it from burning. Microwaves have different power capabilities, so you may need to experiment with the cooking times to find the right one for your specific microwave.

How do you cook a frozen quiche?

The quickest way to cook frozen quiche is to toss it in the oven and bake it. This will help reheat the custard, but it will make the crust brown and crispy. Here's how to do it.

Oven re-heat

  1. Preheat your oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit
  2. Place the quiche on top of an oven-safe pan (ceramic or glass for best, but aluminum can also work)
  3. Let the quiche sit in the oven for about 30 minutes. If the quiche was thawed in the refrigerator ahead of time, you only need to reheat it for about 15 to 20 minutes.

Microwave re-heat

You can also place the quiche in the oven microwave to reheat it as well.

  1. To do this, place the quiche on a microwave-safe dish and then set the timer to defrost for about 2-3 minutes.
  2. Next, check the quiche to make sure there aren't it is defrosted. Take a fork and stick it inside the quiche to see if it goes all the way through.
  3. Next, cook the quiche for about two to three minutes to reheat it.

If the quiche was thawed out beforehand, place it in the microwave for about 1 minute to heat it.

How do you fix soggy bottom quiche?

The best way to fix a soggy bottom quiche is to place it in the oven on the bottom rack and reheat it at about 300 degrees Fahrenheit. You'll typically only need to reheat it for about 10 to 15 minutes or until the crust becomes develops a golden brown color or becomes hard again. It's helpful to cover the top of the dish with foil to burn in the process.

Wrapping Things Up

We hope this post has answered your question about how how to rebake undercooked quiche and how to keep it from becoming soggy. Remember, the best way to prevent it from becoming soggy is to ensure that you are preparing the custard and the crust correctly and minimizing the amount of water in the pan before the dish is placed in the oven.

Be sure to check out our other posts before you go:

Can Le Creuset Be Used On Induction Cooktops?

How Long Do Cinnamon Rolls Last? [Room Temperature, Fridge, And Freezer]

Leave a Reply