What Color Cabinets With Butcher Block Countertops?

Figuring out what color cabinets will go with your kitchen counters can be challenging. Do you have butcher block countertops and don't know what cabinet colors will look best? Well, we've done some digging and have a few good ideas to share.

If your kitchen counters have a butcher block design, plenty of cabinet colors will work. A few top choices include:

  • White
  • Black
  • Cream
  • Gray
  • Blue
  • Green

As we begin, we will cover all things butcher block countertops and discuss what cabinetry to choose for them. Whether you love a natural wood look or want something more modern, we're here to help. With that said, let's dive straight into this topic!

Modern wood kitchen with white sink, What Color Cabinets With Butcher Block Countertops?

Choosing A Cabinet Color With Butcher Block Countertops

You want to choose a cabinet color that contrasts the shade of wood your butcher block countertops have.

Generally, this counter design tends to have a more rustic look, so choosing neutral or earth tone cabinets is an easy way to decorate them.

Kitchen butcher block

That said, you can also modernize butcher block countertops by using a bright or bold cabinet color, so this design is easy to work with. You want to consider the undertone of your wood counters when deciding on cabinet color, so try to keep that in mind.


First, we have a simple and modern white cabinet idea for butcher block countertops. Although white cabinetry has more of an up-to-date look than natural wood, the two complement each other nicely in this space.

White Satin Cabinet Paint

This white cabinet paint has a satin finish, high-quality acrylic formula, covers between 350-450 square feet, and comes in a one-gallon container.

Click here to see more on Amazon.


Next, we have another contemporary cabinet color to try using dramatic black paint. Black cabinetry, in general, has a sleek look to it and is also perfect for making butcher block counters feel more modern.

Black Deco Cabinet Paint

This black paint has a satin finish, water-based acrylic formula, covers 50 square feet, and comes in a 31-ounce container.

Click here to see more on Amazon.


Switching gears, we have a more traditional cabinet color for butcher block countertops using cream paint.

Although natural wood and cream cabinetry wouldn't be the first combination that comes to mind, the two work well together in a kitchen and share slightly warm undertones.

Coconut Espresso 1 Day Cabinet Makeover Kit

This cream cabinet kit comes with two cans of 31-ounce paint, a roller, two heads, and a paintbrush, and it has an acrylic formula, satin finish, and covers 100 square feet.

Click here to see more on Amazon.


Next up, we have a light grey cabinet idea that works perfectly for butcher block counters.

If you want to brighten up your room but don't want to go with white paint, softer grey cabinets are a great way to reflect natural light and give your kitchen a newer feel.

Driftwood Cabinet Paint

This light grey paint has a satin finish, high-quality acrylic formula, covers 50 square feet, and comes in a 31-ounce container.

Click here to see more on Amazon.


For those wanting a more vibrant cabinet color, blue is a great option to try. Although any shade of blue is fine, a deeper tone looks great with wood countertops and pairs so nicely together for a kitchen design.

Oxford Blue 1 Day Cabinet Makeover

This cabinet makeover kit comes with two 31-ounce paint cans, a roller brush and two heads, a paintbrush, has a satin finish, low VOC acrylic formula, and covers 100 square feet.

Click here to see more on Amazon.


Lastly, we have a deep green cabinet color suggestion for butcher block counters.

As mentioned, going with a more subtle, natural-looking cabinet design is an easy way to compliment butcher block countertops and follow their already earthy aesthetic.

Painter's Touch Green Latex Paint

This green paint has a satin finish, oil-based acrylic formula, works on wood and metal surfaces, is full coverage, and comes in a 32-ounce can.

Click here to see more on Amazon.

Are Butcher Block Countertops High Maintenance?

For anyone debating whether butcher block countertops are for them, expect frequent upkeep.

This counter style can be high maintenance and needs constant care to stay in good shape, so we don't recommend it for the faint of heart.

Butcher block countertops need to be regularly treated with mineral oil and even sanded down depending on how often you use them.

This counter style will require more attention than marble and other stone options, so it might not work for everyone.

Mineral Oil

This mineral oil is food-grade quality, works on butcher block countertops, seals and protects wood, and comes in a 12-ounce bottle.

Click here to see more on Amazon.

How Much Do Butcher Block Countertops Cost?

You can usually expect to pay anywhere from $40 to $100 per square foot if you want your kitchen to have butcher block counters.

In general, 50 square feet of butcher block countertops will cost you around $2,000 to $5,000 to purchase and install, so this isn't cheap.

That said, every kitchen is different, but you should budget at least $2,000 for your new wooden countertops.

Read more: How Much Do Butcher Block Countertops Cost? [By Size, Type, Grain, And Brand]

Is Butcher Block Cheaper Than Granite?

Kitchen counter with empty wall

Between the two, butcher block countertops will generally cost less than granite. Although harder to maintain, wood is a fairly affordable material and won't be as expensive as stone options.

On top of that, butcher block counters have different grades, which their grain, quality, and thickness all determine, so pricing will depend on those details.

What Is The Best Wood For Butcher Block Countertops?

Maple wood is one of the best options for a butcher block countertop when it comes to quality. Cherry and red oak are also great options if you want vibrant colored countertops, so there are plenty of choices.

Another wood you can use is bamboo for butcher block counters, although it works best for end-grain construction. Regardless, make sure to find a color that blends well with your cabinetry and other kitchen elements.

What Can You Not Do With Butcher Block Countertops?

When it comes to things you should avoid doing to a butcher block countertop, there are a few important ones. Some common mistakes include:

  • Placing hot cookware directly on your wood counters
  • Leaving excess water on your butcher block countertop
  • Cutting/preparing food directly on your wood surface
  • Not keeping up with regular counter maintenance/cleaning

Although these are just a few main things to avoid when dealing with wood countertops, remember to keep them as clean and dry as possible between uses.

How Often Should You Clean Butcher Block Counters?

Ideally, you should clean your butcher block countertops every time you use them. Even for those who don't cook often, it's important to wipe down your wood counters every few weeks to maintain their quality.

It's recommended to clean unused butcher block surfaces at least every two months to keep them in good condition, so try to form that habit.

For products, we suggest using either a warm soapy sponge or an all-natural wood cleaner on your butcher block counters.

All Natural Wood Cleaner

This natural wood cleaning soap works on butcher block countertops, will eliminate stubborn odors, is made in the USA, and comes in an eight-ounce bottle.

Click here to see more on Amazon.

How Long Does A Butcher Block Countertop Last?

Loft kitchen design

You can generally expect a butcher block countertop to last you around 20 years on average. This is comparable to granite counters, so butcher block designs are a great long-term option.

Generally, as long as you oil/reseal wood countertops monthly, you should see them last for decades to come, so upkeep is essential.

Choosing a high-quality countertop will also play a big role in its lifespan, so try to splurge if possible.

Are Butcher Block Countertops Out Of Style?

Although everyone has a different opinion, no, butcher block countertops are not out of style. Wood has a timeless charm to it, which makes it perfect for any kitchen design.

Cabinet color can also affect how up-to-date your butcher block counters look, so try to stick with black, white, grey, or even blue paint.

To Wrap Things Up

Whether you have butcher block countertops or plan to install them, choosing the right cabinet color is essential. We found that colors like white, black, cream, grey, blue, and green will all work well with this countertop design.

When it comes to maintaining wood counters, this does require frequent oiling/cleaning, so keep that in mind.

Style-wise, there are endless ways to decorate a butcher block countertop, so they work for all kinds of aesthetics.

Regardless, remember to use colors with similar undertones for your kitchen, and don't forget to wipe down your wood countertops each time you use them.

Check out these helpful kitchen posts below:

Cutting Board Vs. Butcher Block - What Are The Differences?

What Oil Is Best For Butcher Block Or A Cutting Board?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *