Are You Supposed To Cook Uncrustables?

Uncrustables are a fan favorite for kids and adults alike. The frozen, premade sandwiches are easy to grab and go, making them a convenient option for busy families. But are you supposed to cook these delicious snacks before eating? Let's take a look.

Uncrustables do not need to be cooked before eating. The sandwiches purchased are frozen and are meant to be thawed and eaten as is. However, that doesn't mean you can't cook them if you'd like!

Like Hot Pockets, Uncrustables are a quick and easy snack that can be enjoyed when you are short on time. In this article, we will discuss whether or not you are supposed to cook Uncrustables before eating. In addition, we will answer other frequently asked questions about Uncrustables, so read on!

Close up view of Uncrustables for sale in the freezer section of a Target store. - Are You Supposed To Cook Uncrustables.

Do You Heat Up Uncrustables?

Uncrustables are lunchbox-ready sandwiches, which means they come frozen and do not require cooking before eating. But what exactly are Uncrustables?

Similar to Hot Pockets, Uncrustables are stuffed, pocket-style sandwiches made with bread and various fillings. The difference is that they are round with crimped edges, and the crust is sealed shut with a special machine.

The other main difference between Uncrustables and Hot Pockets is the prep time. Uncrustables are frozen, so all you have to do is thaw and eat. Hot Pockets, on the other hand, should always be cooked, whether it's with an oven, microwave, or air fryer.

On the Uncrustables website, they don't recommend using any cooking method to heat up the sandwiches. The reason why isn't explained, but it could be due to the type of bread used or the fillings.

Heat could also change the texture of the stuffed sandwich. Hot Pockets have a thicker and doughier crust, so they can withstand the heat better.

Uncrustables are softer and more delicate, so heating them up might make the crust soggy and the filling runny. Nonetheless, it doesn't mean you can't experiment.

There are some who have put them in the air fryer with success. Just be sure to monitor the sandwich closely, as you don't want the bread to become too crispy.

You can also give the ham and cheddar or turkey and colby jack flavors a try. You might be surprised at how good they taste when warmed up!

Microwaving is also an option, but you won't get the crispiness that you would with an air fryer. If you do choose to microwave your Uncrustable, start by microwaving it for 10 seconds.

Grocery store shelf with boxes of Smucker's brand Uncrustables. Hazelnut, grape jelly and strawberry. White bread and whole wheat.

What Is The Best Way To Thaw Uncrustables?

It's important to leave Uncrustables frozen until you are ready to enjoy one. This will ensure the best flavor and texture.

When you are ready to eat your Uncrustables, there are a few different ways you can thaw it out. The best way is to thaw the sandwich at room temperature for 30-60 minutes before eating.

If you don't want to eat it right away, then you can refrigerate the sandwich for 6-8 hours. You can still eat Uncrustables after that, but for best results, try to eat them within 24 hours.

Another way to thaw Uncrustables is in the microwave. This is not the recommended method, as it can make the bread soggy.

How Long Do Uncrustables Last In The Freezer?

Even though they are frozen food, Uncrustables have a surprisingly short shelf life. If stored properly in the freezer, they will last a month or longer from the purchase date.

After a month, you should check the sandwich for freezer burn. If there are any frost or ice crystals on the bread, it's best to throw it out.

The fillings might still be good, but the bread will most likely be dry and crumbly. If you do decide to eat it, make sure to toast the bread first.

It is also recommended not to thaw and then refreeze Uncrustables. Once they are thawed, the clock starts ticking, and you have a limited time to eat them.

If you do refreeze Uncrustables, you will be left with a soggy sandwich that is no longer appetizing.

Close up view of Uncrustables for sale in the freezer section of a Target store.

What Flavors Do Uncrustables Come In?

While they don't have nearly as many flavors as Hot Pockets, Uncrustables still has a variety of flavors to choose from. Here is the list of Uncrustables flavors:

  • Peanut butter and grape jelly
  • Peanut butter and grape spread
  • Peanut butter and strawberry jam
  • Peanut butter and strawberry spread
  • Peanut butter and honey spread
  • Chocolate flavored hazelnut spread
  • Uncured ham and cheddar cheese
  • Turkey and colby jack

As you can see, there is plenty of options for snack, lunch, or dessert. For parents who are short on time, Uncrustables can be a lifesaver.

Unfortunately, for those who have gluten sensitivities, Uncrustables are not the snack for you. In addition, Uncrustables do not meet vegan dietary needs.

Is It Safe To Eat A Frozen Uncrustables?

It's completely safe to eat frozen Uncrustables. In fact, some people enjoy the taste and texture of a frozen sandwich.

Of course, you still need to ensure that Uncrustables are safe to eat. In other words, they need to be within the expiration date.

In addition, check for freezer burn or other signs of spoilage. If everything looks good, then go ahead and enjoy your sandwich!

Are Uncrustables Healthy To Eat?

Like most frozen foods, Uncrustables are not exactly healthy. They don't meet FDA and USDA definitions of healthy foods. In other words, they aren't low fat, low in saturated fat, have less than 90 mg of sodium, and don't contain enough nutrients to be considered healthy.

Uncrustables only have between 140-210 calories per sandwich, which is not bad for a snack or light meal. However, since Uncrustables are small, you might be tempted to eat more than one.

In addition, Uncrustables have a fair amount of sugar and sodium. If you are watching your sugar or salt intake, then you might want to avoid Uncrustables.

Finally, some people might have concerns about the preservatives in Uncrustables. If you are worried about these ingredients, then you might want to find another snack.

Overall, Uncrustables are not the healthiest option out there. If you eat them in moderation, they can be a part of a balanced diet. Cheat snack, anyone?

What Do They Do With the Crusts From Uncrustables?

If you are wondering, they are called Uncrustables because the crusts are removed before they are frozen. The crusts are then used to make animal feed.

With all of the food waste in the world, it's reassuring to know that Uncrustables are doing their part to reduce waste. So, if you are ever feeling guilty about eating an Uncrustable, just remember that the crust is going to a good cause!

Where Can You Buy Uncrustables?

If you are looking to get your taste buds on some Uncrustables, you can find them in most grocery stores. They are usually located in the frozen food section.

In addition, you can purchase Uncrustables online from a variety of retailers. If you have trouble finding them in stores, then buying them online is a great option.

You can also use the store finder on the Uncrustables website to locate a store near you that sells Uncrustables.

Box of Smucker's uncrustables on an isolated background

How Much Do Uncrustables Cost?

The cost of Uncrustables varies depending on the retailer, how many are in a pack, and the flavor. Uncrustables come in packs of 4, 8, or 10, ranging from $4-12.

In other words, you are spending, on average, $1 per Uncrustable. While this might seem like a lot, remember that you are paying for the convenience of having a quick and easy snack or meal.

You are also paying for the packaging when you buy Uncrustables. To some, the convenience is worth the extra cost. After all, it means that you can grab an Uncrustable and go without having to do any prep work.

Can You Make Homemade Uncrustables?

If you want to save money and have some fun in the kitchen, you can make your own Uncrustables. All you need is some bread, a dough crimper, and fillings of choice.

Follow these steps to make your own Uncrustables:

  1. Take two slices of bread and spread your choice of ingredients such as peanut butter and grape jelly.
  2. Put the two slices of bread together.
  3. Next, take your dough crimper and seal the edges of the two slices of bread.
  4. Place your Uncrustables on a baking sheet and freeze for two hours.
  5. From there, you can either thaw them for a school lunch or put them in a freezer-safe bag for future use.

Making your own Uncrustables is a great way to save money and customize your sandwiches. You can also have fun experimenting with different flavor combinations.

Final Thoughts

 A view of several packages of Smucker's Uncrustables sandwiches on display at a local big box grocery store.

Uncrustables are a quick and easy snack for kids and even adults. While they were originally meant to be thawed and eaten, you can eat them frozen or heat them up.

Made it to the end? Here are other articles you might enjoy:

How Long Does A Hot Pocket Last In The Freezer?

How Long To Put Hot Pockets In Microwave?

Does A Quiche Have To Be Refrigerated?

Leave a Reply